Work

Unravelling healthcare professionals’ (de)motivating interaction styles: a Self-Determination Theory perspective

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Patient motivation to engage in therapy, self-management, and lifestyle changes is a key determinant of effective and sustainable health outcomes. Healthcare professionals (HCPs) play a crucial role in shaping this motivation by the way they interact with their patients. Yet many complaints from patients are about HCPs’ interaction styles and one in three patients feel demotivated for therapy, addressing the need to better understand this motivational process. Chapter I provides a general introduction outlining the importance of this research and introducing the key variables and their relationship within the Self-Determination Theory (SDT), thereby setting the stage for the overarching aim of this dissertation. Specifically, this dissertation aims to advance a nuanced understanding of SDT-based motivational processes in health care by clarifying insight into HCPs’ motivating (i.e. autonomy-support and structure) and demotivating (i.e. control and chaos) interaction styles toward patients, ultimately contributing to improved patient care. To address this overarching aim, four empirical studies were conducted, which are presented in the following chapters. Chapter II examines how patients’ perception of their physiotherapist’s or occupational therapist’s interaction styles is associated with patient outcomes. Specifically, it examines how patient-perceived motivating and demotivating interaction styles are associated with patients’ basic psychological needs, their motivation to engage in therapy, and components of therapy adherence. Chapter III explores possible antecedents of physiotherapists’ and occupational therapists’ motivating and demotivating interaction styles. More specifically, it explores how HCP-perceived engaging leadership and patient involvement are associated with HCPs’ basic psychological needs, their work motivation, and their motivating and demotivating interaction styles. Chapter IV adopts a person-centered approach to identify interaction profiles among physiotherapists, nurses, and midwives in education and explores profile differences in demographics, SDT-based beliefs, and self-management support. Finally, Chapter V presents a quasi-experimental pre-test post-test control group design among physiotherapists in education, investigating the effectiveness of an SDT-based course module on their motivating and demotivating interaction styles and their self-management support competencies. The module comprised a theoretical component on SDT and a practical component embedded in their internship, in which students observed and reflected on their video-recoded treatment session. Across the chapters, a consistent pattern appears to emerge in how HCPs interact with patients. Overall, HCPs seem to apply more motivating than demotivating interaction styles. However, a potential interesting discrepancy was observed, HCPs tended to report lower levels of demotivating interaction styles (Chapters III and IV) than patients reported perceiving from their HCP (Chapter II). Chapter IV further showed that HCPs may combine these interaction styles to different extents, identifying five distinct profiles. Chapters III and IV found that female HCPs tend to apply more motivating and less controlling than men toward patients. Differences across healthcare professions also appeared, as well as differences between HCPs’ in practice and in education, although these patterns were less consistent. At the patient-level, Chapter II found that patients’ perceived autonomy-support was positively related to need satisfaction and negatively to need frustration. Perceived control was positively related to need frustration. Need satisfaction, in turn, was positively related to intrinsic motivation, integrated, identified and introjected regulation to engage in therapy, while need frustration showed a negative relationship with intrinsic motivation and introjected regulation, and a positive association with external regulation and amotivation to engage in therapy. Integrated and identified regulation to engage in therapy were positively related to treatment adherence, while external regulation and amotivation showed negative associations. At the HCP-level, Chapter III found that physiotherapists’ and occupational therapists’ perceptions of their leader (engaging leadership) and patient involvement were both positively related to their need satisfaction and negatively to need frustration. Need satisfaction was positively related to autonomous and controlled motivation for work, need frustration was positively related to autonomous motivation, controlled motivation, and amotivation for work. Autonomous motivation was positively and controlled motivation negatively related to providing autonomy-support and structure to patients. Autonomous motivation was also positively related to control, and amotivation showed positive associations with controlling and chaotic interaction styles. Chapter IV demonstrated that motivating and demotivating interaction styles tend to co-occur within physiotherapists, nurses, and midwives in education. Those in the least favorable interaction profiles (labeled demotivating and inactive) reported lower SDT-based beliefs and self-efficacy in self management support compared with HCPs in the most favorable profiles (i.e. labeled motivating and active). A fifth profile, labeled undifferentiated, showed mixed patterns. Finally, Chapter V indicated that physiotherapists in education may benefit from an SDT-based course module. Participants of the intervention group displayed improvements in both motivating and demotivating interaction styles, SDT-based beliefs, and self-efficacy of self-management support. In conclusion, parallels emerged between the motivational processes of patients and HCPs, aligning with findings from other domains. Specially, the results highlight a bright pathway, in which a positive environment (i.e. patients’ perceived autonomy-supportive interaction style, and for HCPs, perceived engaging leadership and patient involvement) is positively related to need satisfaction, which in turn is positively related to high-quality types of motivation, and to positive outcomes (i.e. for patient components of therapy adherence, and for HCPs, motivating interaction styles). Conversely, a dark pathway was observed, in which a negative environment (i.e. patients perceived controlling interaction style) is positively related to need frustration, which is positively related to low-quality types of motivation, and to negative outcomes (i.e. HCPs demotivating interaction styles). Additionally, this dissertation suggests a perception gap in both demotivating interaction styles between HCPs’ self-reported and patients’ perception, with patients appear to report higher levels of a controlling and chaotic interaction style. It also provides further evidence for the co-occurrence of motivating and demotivating interaction styles among HCPs, as well as distinct demographic patterns associated with the interaction styles. Together, these cross-domain pathways, along with the observed prevalence and demographic patterns of motivating and demotivating interaction styles, and the intervention-effects of the SDT based course module offer valuable directions for refining the module and enhancing interaction styles to deliver better care. While causal interpretations are limited due to the mainly cross-sectional designs, the assumed directionality is based on theoretical assumptions and evidence from related domains. The findings nevertheless carry practical implications for practicing HCPs, healthcare educational programs, leaders, policy makers, and patients.
Institution: Ghent University
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7224144863
Cites: 199
Cited by:
Related to: 10