Smart-city pilot vs. non-pilot cities: Long-term trends in urban resilience in China
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Urban resilience has become a critical component of sustainable urban development under increasing climate risks and disaster uncertainty. Smart city initiatives have been widely promoted as a strategy to enhance urban governance and resilience. However, their long-term relationship with urban resilience remains insufficiently understood. This study investigates the resilience evolution of 300 Chinese cities, including 155 smart city pilot cities and 145 non-smart cities, from 2004 to 2023. A multidimensional resilience evaluation framework consisting of four dimensions and 48 indicators was constructed, and social network analysis was used to calculate resilience index for each city group and year. The results indicate that pilot cities had a mean resilience index of 0.795, compared with 0.478 for non-pilot cities, and permutation tests showed that this difference was significant in every year. However, the difference was largest in 2004, before the pilot program began, and narrowed mainly before 2013, as the resilience of non-pilot cities increased, and did not widen after the pilot program began. Given the non-random selection of pilot cities, these differences should be interpreted as an association that mainly reflects pilot selection rather than a direct causal effect of smart city policies. Early smart city pilots showed higher and comparatively stable resilience (mean 0.935) than the second (0.621) and third (0.180) batches. Institutional and infrastructure resilience increased in both groups, agent resilience changed little, and environmental resilience declined in both pilot and non-pilot cities, suggesting persistent challenges in ecological sustainability. The findings suggest that smart-city policy evaluation should account for baseline differences, and that future resilience-oriented policies strengthen environmental integration and support for less developed cities alongside technological advancement.
Source: Sustainable Cities and Society
Authors: Yongzhu Zhang, Shiyao Zhu, Fan Zhang, Dezhi Li
Language: English
Subfield: Urban Studies
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,870
OpenAlex ID: W7224749566
