Eudaimonia and Immortality - Personal identity and the sense of purpose through the prism of immortality
Type: book
Abstract: The paper wishes to contribute to the Makropulos-debate about immortality – but not in the sense of whether or not immortality would be desirable. It would instead ask two questions: 1) Is Williams’ view on the tedium of immortality compatible with his definitions of personal identity and moral integrity? 2) Can a study of identity and purpose in immortality contribute to and illuminate our own, mortal quest for meaning, identity, purpose and a personal philosophy more suitable for mortal as well as immortal lives? To answer the first question we will use two literary examples. The character of Elina Makropulos from the opera that inspired Bernard Williams’ 1973 essay on the tedium of immortality, and a counter-example, Hob Gadling, created by Neil Gaiman, one of the rare figures in fiction who becomes immortal and never regrets it. We will apply Williams’ later writings on personal identity and purpose on these two depictions of immortality. To answer the second question we will distinguish between externally and internally defined personal identities as well as an externally and internally supplied sense of purpose and investigate which one is better suited for an immortal life. In the spirit of Bernard Williams and virtue ethics we will convert our conclusions to practical advice, apply them to the quest for eudaimonia – or the good life – in immortality, and hope that it will yield some answers for our own, mortal lives as well.
Author: Nova, Eszter
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225071024
