Work

Beyond Jobless Growth: Structural Transformation and Labor Market Heterogeneity in India, 1983–2023

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Using harmonized microdata from nationally representative labour force surveys for 1983–2023, this paper examines how structural transformation has reshaped the composition and welfare of workers in India. It revisits the widely held view that the post-reform period has been one of “jobless growth”, with persistent nonformal employment and limited expansion of regular salaried jobs. Rather than treating “non-formal” employment which includes the self-employed, casual and unpaid workers, as a homogeneous residual sector, we show that welfare outcomes vary substantially across these different employment categories. To examine the sources of this heterogeneity, the paper combines shift-share analysis with Oaxaca-Blinder and recentered influence function (RIF) Oaxaca decompositions to distinguish the contributions of differences in worker characteristics from differences in their associated coefficients (coefficient effects). The analysis reveals substantial heterogeneity within India’s “nonformal” workforce. Casual workers experience persistent welfare disadvantages relative to the self-employed, particularly in urban areas, while the welfare position of unpaid household workers varies across rural and urban areas, welfare quantiles, and macroeconomic phases. Some self-employed workers attain welfare levels that are comparable to those of regular salaried workers in certain quantiles and phases. By disentangling differences in observed characteristics from differences in their conditional associations, this paper shows that the conventional jobless-growth narrative hides substantial hetero-geneity in the welfare outcomes associated with different forms of employment. The persistence of nonformal employment with substantial differences in worker welfare therefore does not necessarily imply uniformly lower welfare outcomes. The paper provides a more nuanced understanding of India’s labour market transformation over the past four decades. JEL: C21, J21, J46, O15, O17
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225108066
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10