Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation is focused on the studies of biased policing in the United States. It is centered on two research questions: 1) under what circumstances can reforms efforts and processes curb discriminatory policing, and 2) whether police discrimination is intersectional in its nature, considering in particular historically criminalized groups such as racialized and queer people. To answer these questions, I combine use a combination of different research designs and take advantage of administrative records of police stops from Illinois (papers 1 & 2), Los Angeles, and San Francisco (paper 3). To study the (in)successes of different reform processes, I study the effect of two marijuana policies passed in Illinois (paper 1) and of Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests in Chicago in 2020 – a contrast between top-down legislative reform and a bottom-up process channeled by social movements and demonstrations. Findings show that while marijuana reform failed to deliver on curbing police profiling, likely due to inertia and resistance among police ranks, the BLM protests managed to deeply change police tactics in Chicago, significantly reducing disparities in stops, searches, and arrests, with no negative spillovers on crime. Finally, the third paper uses an intersectional approach to study the interaction between queerness and racial status in determining patterns of police discrimination. The analysis displays the existence of an intersectional, double-disadvantage for civilians who belong to a racial minority and are perceived as queer. These empirical contributions inform important theoretical debates on the institutional problems that law enforcement poses to reform efforts at a time of heightened public attention towards policing, as well as on the role of the police in reproducing the structural discrimination of different marginalized communities.
Author: Murgolo, Emanuele
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225132108
