Work

Hidden in plain-sight: ICD-10/SnoMed reasons why thousands of NHS patients with pulmonary arteriovenous malformations are missed by major rare disease initiatives

Year: 2026
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Background Resource allocations and research priorities rely increasingly on digital capture of disease prevalence. The importance of pulmonary arteriovenous malformations (PAVMs) was evident in the 2005-2014 US Nationwide Inpatient Sample database where PAVMs caused 0.02% of 4,271,910 acute ischemic stroke admissions,1 yet in the UK, PAVMs were not among 331 rare diseases captured to <10 cases across 58,162,316 individuals.2 Methods To test if NHS-based coding systems were preventing recognition, we reviewed methods of2; searched Orphanet, ICD-10, SnoMed and ICD-11 for ‘pulmonary arteriovenous malformation’ or ‘pulmonary arteriovenous’; and queried an institutional pseudonymised Rare Disease database for face-to-face reviews. Results Inclusion in2 required an Orphanet code that mapped to clinically-validated ICD-10 or SnoMed terms, and a diagnosed, alive patient on 23 January 2020. ‘PULMONARY ARTERIOVENOUS MALFORMATION’ retrieved ORPHA:2038 with an appropriate descriptor, but ‘No results found!’[in red] from ICD-10, and 303070000 from SnoMed, where cases required prior surgical cavopulmonary anastemoses (table 1). ‘PULMONARY ARTEROVENOUS’ retrieved ORPHA:2038 and two ICD-10 codes: One was appropriate (I28.0), but carried obsolete descriptors and anatomical inaccuracies (‘arteriovenous fistula of pulmonary artery vessels’). The second, Q25.7 (‘Other congenital malformations of pulmonary artery’) linked to SnoMed 303070000 which referred to the post-surgical complication (table 1). None of the 1,149 radiologically-confirmed PAVM cases in the NHS institutional database had undergone cavopulmonary anastemoses, so none would meet the criteria for pulmonary arteriovenous malformation coding in SnoMed. Of the 945 cases identified by 31.12.2020, 130 had a post 2020-2026 face-to-face review confirming alive status at the censor date. Since alive patients were missed, we tested if ICD-11 would have improved recognition. This separates the post-procedural disorder (BE14.B) from natural pathologies, but 2 separate diseases map to LA90.5 (‘pulmonary arteriovenous malformation’ and ‘pulmonary arteriovenous aneurysm’) and >5 diseases/normal physiological states to BB02.0 (table 1). Conclusion NHS patients with radiologically-confirmed PAVMs are missed in NHS-wide datasets based on ICD-10/SnoMed, despite a valid, unique Orphanet Code, because of aetiology-limiting, non-unique and/or inaccurate ICD-10/SnoMed codes that will not survive quality assurance and validation step filters. ICD-11 would not have improved. Urgent updates are required to reduce current inequities in service provision, training, funding and research. References Topiwala. Stroke 2021. PMID:34082575. Thygeson-lancet. Digit Health 2025. PMID:39890245.
Source: Thorax
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7225249746
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10