Work

पूर्वपक्षः — The Opponent First: the Research Gap

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Pūrvapakṣa, "the prior view", is the opposing position that a śāstra states in order to answer it. Kauṭilya defines it as "a statement to be refuted", with the thesis of Bhāradvāja that he goes on to reject: "of a calamity of the king and a calamity of the minister, the minister's calamity is the graver." Suśruta defines it as "a question preceded by an objection": "how can the four kinds of prameha caused by vāta be incurable?" Cakrapāṇi defines it as "a statement that damages an asserted matter", and points to a debate in Caraka's symposium on incompatible foods, where Ātreya's rule that fish should not be eaten with milk is challenged by Bhadrakāpya: all fish may be eaten with milk except the cilicima. The same word names the plaint in legal procedure, and the second member of the Mīmāṃsā and Vedānta topic. This article shows that the three definitions describe three forms of opposition — a rival thesis, an objecting question, and a counter-statement from a peer — and argues that the strength of a śāstra depends on the strength of its pūrvapakṣa. It answers three objections: that stating a view only to refute it is wasteful, that a pūrvapakṣa invites the setting up of a weak opponent, and that Suśruta's "question" is not a statement to be refuted. It concludes that pūrvapakṣa is the device by which a śāstra earns its conclusions, and that its modern forms are the research gap, the rival hypothesis and the reviewer's objection. Series: तन्त्रयुक्तिविमर्शः · Tantrayukti Studies, TY-2026/25. Loci: AŚ 15.1.53–54; Su. Utt. 65.25. Online version: https://sanskritmanthan.in/a/ty-25-purvapaksha
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225265177
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10