Work

अनेकान्तः — In Some Cases, Not in Others: Contextual Truth

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Anekānta, "not of one end", is the device by which a śāstra states that something holds in some cases and not in others. It is the counterpart of ekānta (TY-27) and appears only in the medical lists. Suśruta defines it as "'in some places thus, in others otherwise'", with a debate on what is primary in a medicine: "some teachers say the substance is primary, some the taste, some the potency, some the post-digestive effect." His own chapter on the subject sets out the four views and concludes that the wise accept all four together, since a substance acts sometimes by itself, sometimes by its potency, sometimes by its taste and post-digestive effect. Cakrapāṇi, under the name naikānta, defines it as "the non-determination of either side", and cites Ātreya's reply to Maitreya in Caraka's tenth chapter: not all patients given medicine will recover. This article distinguishes the tantrayukti from two other uses of the same word — the Nyāya fallacy of the inconclusive reason (anaikāntika) and the Jaina doctrine of many-sidedness (anekāntavāda) — and answers three objections: that anekānta is mere indecision, that it is the fallacy of the inconclusive reason, and that it makes a śāstra's teaching unusable. It concludes that anekānta is the device of context-dependent truth, and that its modern forms are effect modification, heterogeneity of treatment effect, the conditional finding and the honest "it depends" — each requiring that the conditions be named. Series: तन्त्रयुक्तिविमर्शः · Tantrayukti Studies, TY-2026/34. Loci: Su. Utt. 65.24; Ca. Si. 12.43. Online version: https://sanskritmanthan.in/a/ty-34-anekanta
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225275856
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10