Work

Algorithmic Governance and the Validity of Law: Re-examining H.L.A. Hart’s Rule of Recognition in the Age of Automated Decision-Making

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: As automated decision-making becomes more common in public administration and adjudication, a jurisprudential question about algorithmic decision-making that cannot be answered by algorithmic fairness discussions is what makes an algorithmically mediated exercise of public power legally authoritative? This article presents a doctrinal and conceptual analysis of some of the open-access scholarship published in the most recent five years (2021-25), revisiting H.L.A. Hart's rule of recognition. It separates the validity of the legal norm, the authority to enforce the legal norm and the legality of specific decisions. The most recent studies on legal positivism, rules as code, automated adjudication and institutional accountability reveal that computational systems can help to reshape how law is applied in practice without falling into the trap of acquiring autonomous powers to set sources. The article elaborates an institutionally informed concept of algorithmic legal authority based on authorization, normative traceability and accountable review. It suggests that this framework of Hart works to explain it if the outputs of the algorithms are considered legally mediated institutional acts, but cautions that algorithmic outputs can shift interpretive practices away from the recognised officials in a covert manner. The suggested approach provides a framework which defines areas in which the positivist position is adequate and areas where further protections in public law are necessary.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7225284961
FWCI:
Cites: 26
Cited by:
Related to: 10