Work

Can the use of the "argument from incoherence" help or prevent changing a recipient’s mind?

Year: 2024
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: This paper pursues different interests: argumentation analysis, pragmatics of interaction, and climate ethics. It is commonly understood that the “two wrongs” scheme is connected to the ad personam (Walton, Reed and Macagno, 2008, 160). That rhetorical figure can also be seen in overlap with “whataboutism” and the “Tu quoque”); we argue that a better catchphrase to name it would be “argument from incoherence”. What is of particular interest to me is a version of it taking place in the discussion of climate change. Let us consider the following move: “Why should I follow X when X calls for a ban on fossil fuels, when he/she/they frequently take the plane for conferences and vacations?” First, I will start by clarifying the meaning of the figure by focusing on the “two wrongs” formulation. Secondly, I will discuss whether it can be rejected most of the time or not. Third, there is a substantial interest involved; we cannot avoid displacing the discussion in the field of ethics.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225285347
FWCI:
Cites: 16
Cited by:
Related to: 10