Modified Ternary Concrete for Hydraulic Applications: A Hybrid Bibliometric and Scoping Review of Fly Ash–Silica Fume Systems
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: This review determines whether the 2021–2025 literature on fly ash–silica fume (FA–SF) ternary binders provides optimized, durability-validated compositions for irrigation infrastructure, whose rehabilitation in arid Central Asia requires durability grades (frost resistance ≥ F300, water impermeability ≥ W8) that conventional concrete rarely achieves. A two-stage hybrid review was conducted. Stage 1 mapped 1416 deduplicated Scopus records in VOSviewer 1.6.20 (keyword co-occurrence, bibliographic coupling, co-citation). Stage 2 screened the 25 top-ranked articles against explicit eligibility criteria (10 formed the FA–SF core subset) and coded them with a 24-item codebook; AI-assisted coding was validated by the first author and checked on a 24% sample by a second coder. Publication output rose 2.6-fold, but compressive strength was reported in every coded article, whereas frost resistance appeared in 8% (95% CI 2–25%), water impermeability in 16%, and sulfate resistance in 20%. Targeted searches (120 records screened) found 17 design-of-experiments studies with FA–SF durability responses and 4 FA–SF studies for hydraulic structures. Only one combined formal experimental design with FA–SF concrete for water-conveyance channels, and it addressed abrasion alone. No study optimized a ternary binder for the frost–impermeability–sulfate profile governing canal linings in continental climates, leaving a narrow but well-defined gap for canal-trough concrete design.
Source: Construction Materials
Institution: Satbayev University
Language: English
Subfield: Civil and Structural Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,207
OpenAlex ID: W7225315772
