Work

From Enabling to Empowering:Reconceptualising the Teacher Librarian’s Influence on School Reading Cultures

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: As in many countries (Loh et al., 2025; Organisation of Economic Co-operation, 2024), Australian adolescents are experiencing a marked decline in reading engagement, highlighting a critical disconnect between the skill to read and the will to read. While students reportedly possess the necessary literacy skills (Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority, 2026b; De Bortoli et al., 2024), voluntary reading rates continue to drop (Rutherford et al., 2024; Wright et al., 2025). Within the Australian school context, the Teacher Librarian (TL) is positioned at the centre of this tension. Professional library associations and educational literature assert that the TL plays a crucial role in supporting students to develop both the skill and will to read (Australian Library and Information Association & Australian Coalition of School Libraries, 2025; Merga, 2019). However, despite decades of advocacy from the school library sector championing this value (EBSCO, 2017; House of Representatives Education and Employment Committee, 2011; Lance & Kachel, 2018; Lonsdale, 2003), there remains a significant gap in understanding the precise mechanisms of how TLs exert influence within complex school ecologies. This research sought to address this gap by exploring how TLs navigate institutional structures to empower students to read for pleasure. Grounded in a critical realism paradigm (Bhaskar, 2008; Parra et al., 2021), this research employed a mixed-methods comparative case study (Yin, 2017) across three all-girls secondary schools in Southeast Queensland to investigate the factors that affect TL influence on the school’s reading culture. Data were collected from quantitative surveys of students and teachers; semi-structured interviews with teachers, students, principals, and TLs from each school; and a multimodal analysis of digital artefacts (social media posts) collected from Instagram accounts associated with each school. The empirical findings are structured across four intersecting themes. First, Student Reading Identities revealed a profound skill-versus-will disconnect where a dominant cohort of Proficient Readers possesses high capability but low motivation, placing them on a sliding scale toward reluctance (Gagen-Spriggs & Garrison, 2025, p. 193). Second, Perceptions of Reading Culture uncovered a deep visibility dissonance within the schools, where reading is heavily promoted through performative, event-driven compliance, but remains largely invisible as a daily habit. Third, Systems and Structures established the principal as the primary institutional architect, whose strategic directives enforce rigid structural filters, such as time poverty, curation policies, and staffing allocations, that actively restrict the library’s capacity. Fourth, Perspectives on the Teacher Librarian’s Influence demonstrated how TLs must navigate the school landscape, relying on relational currency and strategic bypasses to maintain their professional agency. Following a cross-case synthesis, this thesis proposes the Conceptual Model of Teacher Librarian Influence. This framework maps how TLs respond to systemic filters through targeted interventions to engineer a sustainable reading culture. Ultimately, this research provides guidance for reconceptualising the TL role, arguing that they must shift from being an “enabling adult” (Chambers, 1991, pp. 87–92; La Marca, 2004, p. 12) who provides resources, to an empowering agent who deploys strategic mechanisms to convert compliance into genuine, autonomous reading engagement.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225441958
Cites: 296
Cited by:
Related to: 10