Closing the Curriculum Delivery Gap in Early Childhood Education: Supervisory Leadership, Quality Assurance and Climate Resilience Across Two Systems
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Early childhood education (ECE) systems worldwide invest heavily in curriculum frameworks, yet a persistent gap separates the curriculum as designed from the curriculum as delivered in classrooms. Drawing on an applied research study that combined comparative policy analysis of Pakistan's ECE frameworks with 836 hours of supervised fieldwork and 120 supervisory audits across early learning centres in Florida, United States, this article argues that the delivery gap is fundamentally a supervisory phenomenon. Findings show that centre directors devoted the majority of their supervisory time to transactional administration rather than instructional coaching; that structured, bi-weekly pedagogical feedback loops were associated with curriculum delivery fidelity rising from 51% to 93%; and that disaster preparedness was most effective when integrated into play-based pedagogy rather than taught as isolated emergency instruction. The article proposes an Integrated Early Childhood Quality and Pedagogical Governance Model (IEC-QPG) organised around pedagogical alignment, supervisory auditing, capacity building, and climate and disaster-risk integration, and discusses its implications for ministries and multi-site ECE operators in both high-income and crisis-vulnerable settings.
Author: Muneeb, Sumaira
Institution: Western Governors University
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225450659