The Symbiotic Experience of Racial Violence: the Impacts of Canadian Immigration Detention and Deportation on Migrants and Families
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: While Canada champions family reunification as a central pillar of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and cultivates a national imaginary as a welcoming and inclusive host, carceral practices of detention and deportation routinely separate, contain, and expel migrants despite their familial connections. This dissertation interrogates this contradiction by asking how ‘the family’ is constructed in political discourses on immigration, how carceral power shapes the everyday lives, relationships, and sense of belonging of migrants and their families, and how migrants and their families affectively experience Canada’s detention and deportation practices. The dissertation examines the expansion of carceral power through ‘the family’ as a microcosm of racial governance. Drawing on theories of racial governmentality, racial capitalism, and affect theory, I advance that the study of migration governance is necessarily a study of carcerality. I develop a racial framework for carceral migration governance, which situates contemporary migration practices within the racial histories of nation-state formation. This theoretical framework importantly centres the racialization processes that govern liberal inclusion and construct the ideal ‘migrant/citizen’ and ideal ‘family.’ I draw on two qualitative methods to examine the racialized material effects of migration governance: a documentary discourse analysis of the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration’s proceedings and final report on “Family Reunification” (2017), and qualitative semi-structured interviews with migrants who have experienced detention and/or deportation (n= 8) and with family members and loved ones of migrants subjected to these systems (n= 12). My analysis demonstrates how the carceral state discursively, materially, and affectively expands into spaces of migration governance and into the lives of the families and loved ones of those it directly targets. The analysis identifies four distinct but interrelated discursive figures that produce political representations of ‘the family’ and ‘the migrant.’ I argue that these figures operate as the racialized prism through which nation-formation is enacted, and the ‘family’ deserving of (re)unification is imagined. I then examine the material and emotional consequences of these discourses within the contexts of detention and deportation. I demonstrate how migration governance is symbiotically experienced within the private, intimate, relational, and communal lives of racialized families. I argue that carceral power transforms the homes, communities, and relationships of families into spaces of capture, surveillance, and expulsion. I also illuminate how carceral power extends to the minutiae of the body. I document an “archive of feelings” (Cvetkovich, 2003), showing how racial carceral violence impresses upon the body, emotions, and senses, structurally producing affective dispositions that haunt families across time and space.
Author: Garneau, Brianna
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: immigration detention, deportation, family reunification, migration governance, racial capitalism, affect theory, racialization, Canadian immigration policy, Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, carceral state, surveillance, racial violence, immigrant families, nation-state formation, Canada
Open Access status: green
Funder: Strong
OpenAlex ID: W7225492068
