AI Judges and Justice Delivery: Will AI Replace Judges? Public Trust and Legal Challenges in Pakistan
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: It is now common for judiciaries around the world to use AI for legal research, case management, risk assessment and decision support, wondering whether machines can eventually replace human judges. In Pakistan, with over two million cases on the docket, the talk is of using AI to cure judicial delay. The Supreme Court of Pakistan in 2025 gave a green signal to the judicious implementation of AI as an aid to justice and emphasized that it should not be used in place of judicial reasoning. The present study explored the perceptions of AI-assisted judicial systems, trust, transparency, accountability and the possibility of AI replacing judges among legal stakeholders in Multan, Pakistan. Convergent parallel mixed methods design was used. A structured questionnaire was used to gather quantitative data from 352 respondents consisting of judicial officers, lawyers, other legal practitioners and law students. Data collection involved in qualitative methods included 24 semi-structured interviews and documentary analysis of legal and policy framework. AI's ability to aid legal research, case management, and reducing backlog was strongly supported, while human judges were not. 9.1 percent would trust a decision made entirely by AI, while 93.2 percent said that a human judge must be held accountable. Judicial officers were the most conservative and law students the most open. The two factors most powerful predictors of support for AI assistance were perceived usefulness and trust. Seven themes emerged from thematic analysis – AI as an assistant rather than an adjudicator, accountability, opacity and the right to a fair trial, data and bias issues, and a regulatory vacuum. The study concludes that augmentation is preferred over replacement among the Pakistani legal fraternity and suggests the implementation of binding judicial guidelines, transparency and human oversight protection, data protection laws and capacity building prior to integrating AI in adjudication.
Institution: Bahauddin Zakariya University
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7225521045
