Work

The Nature of Light:Spatial and Temporal Characteristics of Daylight and Their Influence on Restoration in Indoor Environments

Year: 2026
Type: other
Abstract: Stress and stress-related health problems are an increasing public health concern. Although natural environments support stress recovery, everyday exposure to nature is limited as people spend most of their time indoors, increasing the need for indoor environments that foster restoration. In this context, daylight represents a promising environmental element. Despite extensive evidence for its health and well-being benefits, little is known about its restorative effects indoors or the specific characteristics that contribute to these effects. This thesis therefore asks: To what extent does daylight contribute to the restorative potential of indoor environments, and which characteristics of daylight are instrumental in shaping this potential? The thesis addresses this question iteratively, progressing from a systematic review of existing evidence to increasingly focused experiments on the spatial and temporal characteristics of daylight and sunlight patterns. The systematic literature review presented in Chapter 2 provided promising evidence that daylight has restorative effects indoors. Among the daylight-related factors investigated, opening orientation showed the most consistent evidence of restorative effects, with conditions characterised by the availability of direct sunlight consistently being associated with improved restorative outcomes, provided that visual discomfort was avoided. The review also identified several gaps in the literature, some of which were addressed in the subsequent studies: the scarcity of controlled experiments on the restorative effects of direct sunlight indoors, the lack of research on short-term temporal variations in daylight conditions, such as those occurring in dappled sunlight (sunlight filtered through a tree canopy), and the lack of clarity regarding the mechanisms underlying the restorative effects of sunlight. Chapter 3 reported an online experiment comparing the perceived restoration potential and visual appraisals of photographs of office environments with diffuse daylight, direct sunlight, and dappled sunlight. Direct sunlight showed higher perceived restoration potential than diffuse daylight, although the difference was small and marginally below the threshold for statistical significance. Both direct sunlight conditions were consistently and significantly evaluated more positively across visual appraisal measures than diffuse daylight. Contrary to our expectations, dappled light did not amplify the beneficial effects of direct sunlight. We hypothesised that this outcome might be due to the static nature of the stimulus, which did not represent the temporal variability of dappled light, and therefore proceeded to test dynamic light patterns in the next study. Building on the previous chapters, Chapter 4 investigated the effects of the temporal dynamics of sunlight patterns from nature on stress. In a laboratory experiment, participants were exposed to a dynamic light pattern, a static light pattern, or a uniform control condition projected onto an office wall during a stress-induction protocol. During the stressor task, dynamic dappled light led to lower skin conductance levels than the control condition, indicating a stress-dampening effect, while no effects were found for other stress measures. The dynamic light pattern was also perceived as more attention-grabbing and distracting, suggesting that repeated attentional capture and momentary disengagement from the stressor may provide a restorative experience. However, it remained unclear whether this effect was specific to the natural dynamics of dappled light or could result from any temporal variation. Addressing this question, Chapter 5 examined the effect of motion type in light patterns on stress recovery. Projected light patterns with natural and non-natural motion, alongside a static control condition, were tested in a similar laboratory experiment. To control for the confounding effects of spatial characteristics, the motion of a dappled light pattern was isolated via image processing and applied to abstract light patterns to produce a pattern with natural motion. A corresponding non-natural motion was generated, and a single frame was chosen as the static control condition. Natural motion led to greater stress recovery than non-natural motion, as indicated by heart rate variability, although neither differed from the static control condition and no effects were found for other stress measures. Importantly, the natural motion condition was not perceived as more natural than the other conditions, raising the question of whether explicitly attributing it to a natural source would enhance its restorative potential. Thus, in a follow-up online study, Chapter 6 tested the effects of motion type and source attribution on perceived restoration potential. Consistent with Chapter 5, natural motion yielded higher perceived restoration potential than non-natural motion. However, source attribution neither influenced nor moderated this effect, suggesting that explicit recognition of the natural origin of the motion of the projected light is not necessary for the observed effect. Building on Chapters 5 and 6, which showed that motion type mattered and also that natural motion alone was insufficient to reproduce the restorative qualities of natural dappled light, Chapter 7 examined how temporal and spatial characteristics jointly shape perceived restoration potential. Four features of dynamic dappled light (motion, edge characteristics, luminance gradient, and shape) were manipulated through image processing to create natural and non-natural variants in a full-factorial design. In an online study, conditions were projected onto the photograph of an office wall, and perceived restoration potential and visual appraisals were measured. Results showed that each deviation from naturalness reduced perceived restoration potential, with natural versions of all four features perceived as significantly more restorative than their non-natural counterparts. Importantly, natural motion increased perceived naturalness compared to a no-pattern condition only when combined with certain natural spatial characteristics, indicating that the restorative potential of dynamic dappled light depends on the combination of naturalistic temporal and spatial characteristics. Perceived naturalness was strongly associated with perceived restoration potential but accounted for only 8% of the effect of the condition on perceived restoration potential, indicating that conscious recognition of naturalness was not the primary pathway driving the observed effects. To conclude, this thesis investigated the understudied role of daylight characteristics in shaping restoration in indoor spaces. Our findings demonstrate the importance of direct sunlight and show that the restorative potential of dynamic sunlight patterns is shaped by the combination of both their spatial and temporal characteristics. The findings further demonstrate that beneficial effects associated with daylight can arise through visual and psychological pathways, complementing its well-established (non image-forming) biological effects. Contributing to the methodological portfolio of the domain, this thesis introduces novel image-processing approaches to create and manipulate both static and dynamic visual stimuli, alongside the use of original recordings of natural light. Overall, this thesis makes empirical, theoretical, and methodological contributions to environmental psychology and lighting research and provides a foundation for designing indoor environments that more effectively leverage the restorative potential of daylight.
Language: English
Subfield: Urban Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225540742
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10