Breaking the Killing Jar: The Representation of Women in Twenty-first Century Canadian Opera
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Breaking the Killing Jar: The Representation of Women in Twenty-First Century Canadian Opera examines how contemporary Canadian opera represents women under conditions of aesthetic inheritance, historical pressure, and ethical constraint. Through comparative analysis of seven works—Filumena (2003), Inês (2009), Lillian Alling (2010), Alexandra (2012), Regina (2014), Oksana G. (2017), and Shanawdithit (2019)—the dissertation argues that these operas do not merely recount women’s suffering but interrogate the systems through which women become audible, visible, and narratively legible. A cross-operatic, thread-based framework enables comparison across distinct musical languages, dramaturgical structures, and production contexts. Four analytical chapters examine voice after erasure, feminist archival labour, the ethics of looking at women’s suffering, and the distribution of vocal space as both possibility and constraint. Together, these threads reveal tensions between containment and resistance. Women are positioned within familial, civic, colonial, and mythic structures that constrain voice and agency, yet the operas also create space for endurance, refusal, recovery, and re-voicing. The “killing jar” metaphor captures how operatic and cultural frameworks confine women within repeatable trajectories, even as contemporary works seek to unsettle or reconfigure their boundaries. Methodologically, the dissertation integrates close reading of scores and texts with feminist criticism and dramaturgical analysis, calibrating interpretive claims to available performance documentation. It demonstrates how contemporary Canadian opera contributes to feminist debates about representation, memory, spectatorship, and the ethical risks of making women’s suffering visible. Ultimately, Breaking the Killing Jar positions Canadian opera as a vital site for examining how twenty-first century culture negotiates gender, history, and power through music and theatre.
Author: Bisson, Sophie
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Music
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225557496
