Work

Counted but Unknown: Why reaching the most vulnerable countries is not the same as verifying which people benefit from adaptation finance; and how to establish reach without identifying anyone

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Who are the particularly vulnerable that adaptation finance is for? And did they become less vulnerable because of it? The climate treaties name these people: those "particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change". This working paper reads the full portfolio of the largest dedicated fund, the Green Climate Fund (372 projects, US$21.31 billion, frozen 12 October 2026), against that mandate, in a registered analysis. The good news comes first, and it is real. The Fund sends 62.1 percent of its adaptation funding to Least Developed Countries, Small Island Developing States and African States, above the floor of 50 percent its Board aimed for in 2014. A registered test for underfunding of the most vulnerable countries is defeated under two vulnerability indices. The Fund's simplified approval track reaches first disbursement in 8.8 months, against 14.1 for regular proposals. Then the bad news: the record answers neither question. Nobody can say who these people are, let alone whether they are less vulnerable. The record holds a country and a count, and the count cannot be read as people. By the Fund's own adaptation indicator, adopted in 2014 as the "total number of direct and indirect beneficiaries; number of beneficiaries relative to total population", 18 single-country projects reach more than 100 percent of their country, because the convention lets a project add direct beneficiaries on top of indirect ones, and ten projects count nearly the whole nation as indirect; under the most generous reading, 3 still exceed it. The implementers followed the form; the form cannot tell a resident from a beneficiary. Cost per direct beneficiary runs from US$0.57 to US$143,182. The Fund's own Board paper says why: its framework never specified "how substantial the support must be for a person to be counted". The fix does not require anyone to surrender a name. Confidential reach verification certifies the count, not the person: four tiers, from a population ceiling that needs no personal data to field verification of a sample and deduplication by encoded keys held by a trustee. It can supply the deduplicated beneficiary record that the Fund's harmonized results framework proposes, while the most vulnerable people at the end of the chain remain unnamed and are counted honestly.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225578332
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10