Defence mechanisms and the dimensional model of personality disorder: integrating psychoanalytic constructs in the era of ICD-11
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The ICD-11 reconceptualization of personality disorder around severity of dysfunction and trait qualifiers creates a timely opportunity to reconsider the clinical relevance of psychodynamic constructs. This narrative review examines how defensive functioning may complement ICD-11-based assessment and formulation while remaining conceptually distinct from diagnostic severity and trait description. RECENT FINDINGS: Recent literature supports dimensional approaches to personality functioning and organization and renewed empirical study of defence mechanisms. Emerging evidence links defensive functioning with ICD-11 maladaptive personality traits, while studies using the STIPO-R demonstrate convergence between personality organization and contemporary dimensional models without establishing equivalence. Developmentally adapted measures, including the DSQ-22-A and STIPO-R-A, extend assessment into adolescence. Recent work also highlights differences between self-report and clinician-rated assessment and the potential clinical utility of structured personality assessment. Developmental and mentalization perspectives further situate defensive functioning within affect regulation and interpersonal processes. SUMMARY: Defensive functioning may add a dynamic dimension to ICD-11 formulation by helping to explain how personality dysfunction is organised, expressed, regulated and maintained. It may therefore enrich developmental formulation, therapeutic stance and treatment planning, although direct evidence for incremental prognostic or treatment utility remains limited. Prospective multimethod research is needed to establish its added clinical value.
Source: Current Opinion in Psychiatry
Authors: Yulia Furlong, Sean Hood
Institutions: The University of Western Australia, Curtin University
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225611184
