Work

Outcome Measures in Algebra Intervention Research for Secondary Students with Mathematics Disabilities: A Systematic Review

Year: 2026
Type: review
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: This systematic review examines the outcome measures used to evaluate immediate algebra intervention effects for students with mathematics disabilities in Grades 6–12. Assessment data from a parent project were analyzed to measure characteristics, instructional proximity, and reporting consistent with six indicators adapted from the Council for Exceptional Children standards. Searches completed by 1 March 2025 yielded 27 eligible studies contributing 29 measures, including 22 measures used in single-case design studies. Most measures were researcher-developed (n = 28; 96.6%) and proximal to instruction (n = 28; 96.6%), and individual administration predominated. All 22 SCD measures were administered repeatedly; 19 (86.4%) met the operational criteria for a CBM-aligned approach, whereas 3 were repeated probes with indeterminate CBM status because one or more defining characteristics were insufficiently reported. Only one SCD measure reported empirical alternate-form comparability, and none was independently evaluated for sensitivity to performance change. Although 24 measures met the reliability indicator, 20 reported only scoring agreement. Nine measures met the psychometric-validity indicator, with evidence limited to test content. Only one study paired eligible proximal and distal measures. These findings indicate substantial use of measures proximal to instruction but limited technical evidence supporting repeated-score interpretations and broader claims about algebra learning. Because the review examined reported evidence, missing information should not be interpreted as demonstrating poor measurement quality. Future research should strengthen evidence concerning repeated-score reliability, alternate-form comparability, sensitivity to change, and validity and should combine measures of taught skills with measures of generalization.
Author: Jihyun Lee
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,172
OpenAlex ID: W7225617626
FWCI:
Cites: 50
Cited by:
Related to: 10