Work

An assessment of the Weak Field Approximation

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Interpreting solar spectropolarimetric observations requires an understanding of how variations in atmospheric parameters affect the formation of spectral lines. The weak field approximation (WFA) provides a simple and widely used method to infer magnetic fields from Stokes profiles, but its range of validity and sensitivity to atmospheric conditions are not always well quantified. We aim to study the reliability and limitations of the WFA using generalized response functions (GRFs), which allow us to quantify how the magnetic field inferred by the WFA responds to perturbations in different atmospheric parameters. We derived analytical expressions for the GRFs of the WFA and compute them from synthetic Stokes profiles generated with the SIR and DeSIRe radiative transfer codes. The analysis was performed for a set of photospheric and chromospheric lines under different magnetic field strengths and inclinations. By studying these GRFs, we evaluated the sensitivity of the WFA to the atmospheric structure and assessed its effective range of validity. The GRFs reveal that the magnetic field inferred through the WFA depends on the atmospheric structure, the magnetic field inclination, and the spectral region used in the analysis. For the photospheric lines considered here, the approximation progressively departs from the actual magnetic field as the field strength increases (well before reaching the saturation field), as was theoretically expected. This behavior is related to the loss of linearity between the Stokes V, Q, and U profiles and the derivatives of the intensity profile. The results also show that the transverse-field inference is particularly sensitive to the wavelength range (as it was originally formulated), with the line wings providing more reliable estimates. For the chromospheric lines considered here, the line core and wings clearly probe different atmospheric layers, with the wings providing reliable estimates of the photospheric magnetic field. Our analysis shows that the effective range of validity of the WFA is more limited than commonly assumed. The approximation begins to depart from the actual magnetic field well before reaching the so-called saturation value, and its reliability depends on the magnetic field inclination and on the wavelength range used for the inference. In particular, the choice of wavelength interval is critical for the transverse component, while the wings of chromospheric lines can provide useful information on the photospheric magnetic field. These results are consistent with the original perturbative formulation of the WFA.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,865
OpenAlex ID: W7225703948
FWCI:
Cites: 36
Cited by:
Related to: 10