Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: ABSTRACT History abounds with transformative moral heroes—agents devoting their lives to uprooting entrenched unjust structures. Though philosophy has said much about heroes generally, this distinctive class remains undertheorized. This matters because they are among our most celebrated moral exemplars, and much of our sense of moral progress rests on them. Yet they characteristically act against familiar constraints on responsible deliberation, pursuing apparently infeasible and inefficacious projects while foreclosing tractable alternatives that would secure demonstrable goods. We establish this tension and argue that the most promising attempts to dissolve it fail. At best, this shows that moral theory is structurally conservative, as its standards of responsible deliberation systematically favor mitigation over transformation. At worst, it reveals a deeper instability in moral theory, as it seems to depend for its progress on agents it cannot vindicate.
Source: Philosophy & Public Affairs
DOI: 10.1111/papa.70036
Authors: Meradjuddin Khan Oidermaa, Mac Willners
Institutions: Stockholm University, Institute for Futures Studies
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: moral progress, moral exemplars
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,460
Funder: Vetenskapsrådet
OpenAlex ID: W7225726960
