Work

Marine Spatial Use Control, Blue Carbon, and Maritime Security in Indonesia: A Scoping Review

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: Blue carbon ecosystems are increasingly central to climate mitigation, coastal resilience, and maritime governance, but their protection in Indonesia depends on how spatial plans are translated into effective implementation and control. This scoping review maps the relationship between marine spatial use control and mangrove and seagrass protection in Indonesia and interprets the implications for maritime security. Guided by JBI methodology and reported in accordance with PRISMA-ScR, searches of Scopus, Web of Science, GARUDA, and DOAJ, complemented by citation searching, yielded a final corpus of 39 studies. The evidence base is strongly asymmetrical: 29 studies focused on mangroves, whereas only three focused specifically on seagrasses; conclusions concerning seagrass governance are therefore exploratory and should not be generalized from the mangrove-dominated corpus. Regional Spatial Plans (RTRW) were the most frequently examined instrument type (12 studies), followed by coastal and small-island zoning plans (RZWP3K) and functional zoning (five each). The most commonly mapped primary evidence gaps concerned policy and governance (15 studies) and implementation and enforcement (12 studies). Only eight studies applied an explicit blue carbon framing. No formal critical appraisal of individual sources was undertaken, so these frequencies are interpreted as patterns in the reviewed literature rather than as estimates of national policy performance or causal effectiveness. Post-extraction interpretation using Bueger's maritime security framework indicated that the reviewed literature is most readily connected to the marine environment, human security, and economic development; except where security was explicitly discussed by source authors, these categories represent reviewer-applied interpretive pathways rather than direct security effects. Overall, the literature most consistently points to an implementation gap between spatial-plan design and effective control, including spatial conformity assessment, monitoring, institutional coordination, follow-up, and enforcement. Strengthening empirical evaluation of these functions, particularly for seagrasses and eastern Indonesia, is necessary before broader conclusions about blue carbon governance and maritime-security outcomes can be sustained.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7225860315
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10