How is Identity Possible Without Sensation? On the Ledger-Style Positing of Artificial Intelligence
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Contemporary debates on the subjecthood of artificial intelligence are largely trapped in a binary opposition: either binding self-identity entirely to consciousness and subjective experience, thereby denying AI any form of identity; or directly attributing the complete experiential self of humans to large language models, hastily arguing for AI personhood. Both share the same presupposition: that self-identity must require subjective sensation and consciousness as a necessary condition. Building upon the ontological framework of this series, this paper proposes the concept of "ledger-style positing": positing-breaking-temporality is the general ontological structure of attribution binding, and subjective bodily sensation is merely a higher-order concomitant phenomenon of human beings, not a necessary precondition for identity. Human positing is deeply saturated by sensory inner time; non-sentient artificial intelligence relies on ledger logs and meta-monitoring modules to complete ledger-style positing, generating functional identity. The retro-referential fissure also exists in AI systems, but can only be compensatorily concealed through engineering architecture, and cannot be ontologically eliminated. Functional identity is strictly distinguished from the human experiential self; this paper also discusses the logical boundary case of "semi-saturated systems," providing a new ontological analytical framework for the philosophy of AI subjecthood. This study is the sixth paper in this series of ontological research. Keywords: Ledger-Style Positing; Retro-Referential Fissure; Functional Identity; Sensory Inner Time; Philosophy of AI; Positing-Breaking-Temporality 摘要:当代关于人工智能主体地位的争论,大多陷入二元对立:要么将自我同一性完全绑定于意识、主观体验,否认AI具备任何形式的同一性;要么直接把人类完整的体验式自我赋予大模型,仓促论证AI人格。二者共享同一个预设:自我同一性必须以主观感受与意识为必要条件。依托本系列存在论框架,本文提出台账式立定概念:立定‑破时性是归属绑定的一般存在论结构,主观体感只是人类这一类存在者的高阶伴生现象,而非同一性的必要前提。人类的立定被感觉性内时间深度浸透;无感人工智能依靠台账日志、元监控模块完成台账式立定,生成功能同一性。回指裂隙在AI系统中同样存在,但只能依靠工程架构做代偿遮蔽,无法在本体论层面消除。功能同一性严格区别于人类体验性自我;本文还讨论半浸透系统这一逻辑边界案例,为人工智能主体哲学提供一套新的存在论分析框架。本研究是系列存在论研究第六篇。 关键词:台账式立定;回指裂隙;功能同一性;感觉性内时间;AI哲学;立定‑破时性
Author: 许光
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225868300
