The proper place: Unintended zoning and the internalization of a norm the law does not state
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Regulation of a venue for an activity is also a regulation of every other venue in which that activityhas taken place. This article develops that claim as a mechanism, unintended zoning, and examinesit in Japan’s regulation of online dating services from 2003 to 2026. The statute, written to protectchildren, defined a class of services by their purpose and placed them under supervision. Whethera service fell within the class was left to interpretation after the fact. Drawing on the statute, policeinterpretive standards, the enforcement record, operators’ rules, harassment standards, my ownobservation, and a national survey of how couples met, I show that this created a constraint underwhich each actor did what was best for it. Operators of general services prohibited far more thanthe law addressed, organizers and individuals followed, and only providers able to bear the dutiesof the regime went on performing the function, in the manner of a licensed profession. The otherchannels were driven out. What was internalized is not the rule but its structural result: that anactivity for which a zone exists belongs inside it. The burden falls on those least sure of theirwelcome.
Author: Sophia, Franny Philos
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225871398
