Perbandingan Kemampuan Berpikir Kritis antara Manajer Berpengalaman dan Manajer Pemula dalam Pengambilan Keputusan: Kajian Literatur
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Decision-making is an essential managerial responsibility that involves understanding problems, assessing information, comparing alternatives, and considering risks. This article discusses the relationship between critical-thinking skills, managerial experience, and decision-making, including potential differences in the approaches of novice and experienced managers. It uses a narrative literature review of relevant journal articles and books. The sources are grouped thematically into critical-thinking concepts, managerial experience and competence, decision-making processes, and cognitive biases. One reviewed case study involving five managers in the plasma plantation area of PTPN IV Pelaihari reports the use of divergent thinking to explore alternatives and convergent thinking to narrow choices. The study also identifies managerial experience, time pressure, and information availability as factors influencing decisions. The synthesis suggests that experience can support pattern recognition, but longer tenure does not automatically guarantee better decisions. Decision quality is also associated with the relevance of experience, information quality, problem complexity, cognitive biases, and feedback. These factors may affect novice and experienced managers differently depending on their previous experience, access to information, and organizational environment. Because the reviewed sources do not compare both groups using the same assessment instrument, this article presents a conceptual synthesis rather than empirical evidence that either group is superior. The discussion may inform future research and evidence-based managerial decision practices.
DOI: 10.62710/feksff83
Institution: Universitas Pembangunan Panca Budi Medan
Language: English
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225872422
