The Statistical Invisibility of Honor Killing: A Comparative Assessment of Homicide Reporting across 40 Jurisdictions
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Honor-related deaths may remain in homicide totals but become unidentifiable by motive in published statistics. This documentary study examined selected official sources for 40 purposively chosen jurisdictions available by November 2026. Records were classified according to whether they contained honor-labelled fatal cases, broader honor-related markers, contextual homicide data, general crime data, or evidence that remained unresolved. Three records reported fatal honor-labelled cases, two supplied broader markers, fourteen provided contextual homicide information, fourteen offered general homicide or crime data, and seven remained unresolved. Direct measures differed in their statistical units. Pakistan counted Karo Kari cases, India registered murder cases assigned an honor motive, and Dutch police reviewed specialist files that included historical deaths. England and Wales published a broader series of honor-based abuse offences. No examined source established a complete, comparable, national victim series for 2020–2025. Identification bounds tested how unresolved records affected classification. The findings establish limits on public visibility of motive rather than evidence that homicide victims were omitted from national counts. Cross-national honor-killing rates remain unreliable without compatible victim-level definitions.
Author: Zul Khaidir Kadir
Institution: Universitas Muslim Indonesia
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225874715
