The Synthetic Other: A neurocognitive framework for AI companionship and dependence
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Artificial intelligence (AI) companions can provide emotional support, but the availability, responsiveness, personalization, and affirmation that make them effective regulators may concentrate regulation within a single synthetic relationship. We propose a neurocognitive framework that situates AI companionship along a continuum from regulatory scaffolding to regulatory substitution, linking this transition to distributed systems supporting social-regulatory relief, motivational valuation, self-AI representation, and behavioral control. At the core of the framework is synthetic companion dependence, defined by reduced regulatory substitutability: functions served by a particular companion become increasingly difficult to redistribute across alternative people, strategies, or contexts. We distinguish regulatory scaffolding, which preserves or expands a broader regulatory repertoire, from regulatory substitution, in which regulation becomes concentrated within the synthetic relationship. Regulatory centrality, diminished control, and disruption sensitivity are candidate markers of dependence, whereas persistent displacement or functional impairment marks maladaptiveness. The framework links social-regulatory relief, motivational valuation, self-AI representation, and behavioral control to distributed neurocognitive systems and predicts a progressive shift in the relative neural prioritization of the preferred companion over viable regulatory alternatives. It thereby shifts attention from use intensity to whether regulatory functions remain flexibly replaceable.
Source: PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Authors: Renee Ye, Naem Haihambo, Qi Xiu Fu, Dirk Scheele
Institution: New York University
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225878650
