Work

A Tholonic Psychology of the Individual: Building a Framework of the Psyche from the N-D-C Structure

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A Tholonic Psychology of the Individual: Building a Framework of the Psyche from the N-D-C Structure Two earlier papers in this series, Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such and The Tholonic Psyche in Jung's Language, tested the tholonic N-D-C model against Jung's psychology. They found that the model fits Jung's account of psychic processes (compensation, the reconciling function, the reversal of a one-sided attitude) and fails to fit his catalogue of figures: in a pre-registered test with 3 AI language models as blind coders, the negative aspects of Jung's figures did not follow the positions the model assigned them. This paper draws the consequence. It builds a framework of the individual psyche from the structure itself, keeps what the tests supported, and drops what they did not. The framework has 3 functions: a self-state (N, the organization of goals, self-understanding, and stance that holds at a given time), a bounding function (D, which selects, directs, and excludes), and a receiving function (C, which takes in what the current state excludes). It has 3 processes: differentiation, renewal (bounding and receiving negotiate and a new self-state forms), and instantiation (all 3 functions are present together in one actual moment or act). It has 4 failure types: rigidity (bounding dominates), engulfment (receiving dominates), unsettledness (no self-state holds), and futile activity (negotiation repeats without producing a state). In the pre-registered test of the earlier paper the coders applied these failure types with high agreement, and a figure's failure type did not follow the position the model had assigned it. The framework therefore treats failures as states that any configuration can enter, and recurring inner images as configurations rather than fixed positions. Whether an image keeps one failure type of its own was not tested and is left to prediction P7. The framework overlaps heavily with existing constructs: ego-control and ego-resiliency, assimilation and accommodation, differentiation of self, boundaries in the mind, psychological flexibility, and the personality meta-traits Stability and Plasticity. The paper states the overlap construct by construct. The framework's claim to add anything rests on 7 predictions, stated for pre-registration, with falsification conditions, of which the main ones are: the bounding-side and receiving-side measures form 2 factors, not one bipolar factor; abrupt reversals with hysteresis occur on the bounding-dominant side only; at matched severity, the direction of imbalance predicts inertia versus instability in experience-sampling data; unsettledness and futile activity are failures separable from imbalance; and lasting change is preceded by a window in which both functions are active. No prediction has been tested. The paper proposes a framework and a test plan. It does not claim that the framework is correct, and it does not claim that it is more than a reorganization of existing constructs until the predictions that distinguish it have been run. Version 1.4. Preprint; not peer reviewed. Third paper of a 3-paper series on Jung and the psyche, after Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24151111) and The Tholonic Psyche in Jung's Language (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24151133).
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225879521
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10