How the Future Became a Method: Criterion Jurisdiction, Human Potentiality, and Ontocybernetic Design
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: When institutions define what may count as knowledge, capability, need, or desirable development, their classifications do more than describe an independently settled field: they help constitute the field within which persons and possibilities become recognizable. This essay investigates a specific legitimacy problem generated by that fact. The successful application of a criterion cannot, by itself, justify the criterion's authority over possible forms of life that its application renders invisible. Drawing upon the author's intellectual trajectory in communication studies, constructivist cybernetics, education, literary and artistic experimentation, infosomatics, and civilizational philosophy, I reconstruct the emergence of a future-back ontocybernetic method. Its purpose is neither to predict a preferred future nor to exempt philosophical imagination from empirical constraint. It is to make the admissibility and revisability of consequential criteria an explicit object of inquiry before those criteria become entrenched in institutions or amplified through artificial intelligence. The argument distinguishes actuality from potentiality without treating potentiality as a license for arbitrary projection; specifies criterion jurisdiction, sourcehood, paritary intersubjectivity, and admissibility as mutually constraining concepts; and situates the proposal in relation to second-order cybernetics, Ernst Bloch, backcasting, capability theory, epistemic injustice, classification studies, non-domination, and design justice. It then develops a staged investigative protocol and derives contestable hypotheses for AI-supported education, hospitality, and consequential automated decision-making. Claims grounded in publication records are separated from autobiographical recollection, philosophical reconstruction, and proposed empirical tests. The resulting thesis is reciprocal: actuality must justify its authority to foreclose possibilities; prospective possibilities must justify the consequences of their actualization. The future becomes a method only where both demands remain open to correction by evidence and by the human subjects whose lives are at stake.
Author: Tsvasman, Leon
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225879737
