Recovering Concentric Radii from Edge Measurements: An Expository Analysis of Outside-In Chord-Based Metrology and Assumed Annular Proportions
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: A tapered circular frustum viewed in plan projection forms a pair of concentric circles: a narrower bottom face of radius r (X–Y) and a wider top face of radius R (X–Z). When the frustum is installed under a heavy load or flush against a structure, the central axis X is physically inaccessible and the upper face cannot be spanned directly by a standard caliper, leaving the radial overhang step w = R − r as the only immediate radial measurement. This expository note demonstrates why a purely one-dimensional radial measurement yields an underdetermined system (R − r = w, one equation in two unknowns) regardless of measurement direction, and examines two distinct classes of resolution: (1) Two-Dimensional Edge Triangulation, which closes the metrology problem using one additional external measurement via the classical chord–sagitta theorem (Euclid, Elements III.35) or the 45° corner offset of a circumscribed L-square; and (2) Assumed Proportional Ratios (K = R/r), including the equal-area ratio (K = √2, where r/w = 1 + √2, the silver ratio) and the self-similar golden ratio (K = (1 + √5)/2), which serve as forward design-synthesis rules rather than unknown-object measurement tools. None of the underlying geometric identities are new; the contribution of this note is a self-contained worked metrology derivation, a first-order error-propagation and sensitivity analysis showing how measurement uncertainty is amplified by R/w, a comparison with direct workshop alternatives (circumference tape, two-square caliper, three-point circle fitting), and a boundary assessment of industrial, dendrochronological, and astronomical applications. Version 2.0 revises Version 1.0: formulas are attributed to the classical sagitta/chord theorem and V-block geometry, an error-propagation analysis is added, fixed ratios are reframed as design choices rather than measurement tools, and unsupported application claims are removed.
Author: Fella, Michele
Language: English
Subfield: Mechanical Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225880468
