Mandatory minimums and the limits of federal sentencing reform
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A mandatory minimum limits a judge's ability to impose a shorter sentence even when the judge considers that sentence sufficient. Federal law provides exceptions, but those exceptions have distinct eligibility rules and decision makers. This article examines the relationship between statutory floors, individualized sentencing, substantial assistance, and the safety valve for specified drug offenses. It draws on federal statutes, Sentencing Commission reports, and the Supreme Court's decision in Pulsifer v. United States. The analysis separates being convicted of an offense carrying a minimum from remaining subject to that minimum at sentencing. It also distinguishes descriptive sentence comparisons from proof that a statutory floor caused the entire difference. Existing reforms have provided relief, but access depends on legal criteria that do not simply measure the seriousness of the present offense. The article argues for clearer public accounting of charging decisions, relief eligibility, and the reasons judges cannot impose a shorter term. It favors reviewable individual decisions while acknowledging the public interests in consistency, punishment, victim protection, and safety.
Source: Figshare
Author: Jeremy Koski
Language: English
Topic: Criminal Law and Policy
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225883243
