论承诺作为破时性原型——规范起源的存在论考察
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: On Promise as the Archetype of Breaking-Temporality: An Ontological Investigation of the Origin of Norms The long-standing debate in metaethics concerns whether norms originate from a priori reason, natural order, or human practice. Kantian transcendental practical reason and natural law theory ground norms in pre-existing a priori laws; meanwhile, some reductionist approaches simply equate norms with desires, psychological habits, or social facts. Building upon the ontological achievements of the preceding papers in this series, this paper argues that norms are not a priori ready-made entities, but rather the historical sedimentation of repeated events of positing-breaking-temporality at both individual and public levels. By reconstructing the modal gradient of "must-ought-may-promise-like," this paper points out that this sequence is not a progression of obligatory intensity, but an ontological hierarchical distinction of the sources of constraint: must, ought, and may operate within an already sedimented normative framework; promise is the archetypal operation of breaking-temporality occurring in the undecidable domain, which creates new retroactive normative constraints; "like" is merely a subjective feeling derived after the completion of a promise, and cannot serve as the foundational basis for promising. This paper distinguishes between archetypal promise (the origin-level breaking-temporal creation) and everyday intra-framework promise; the conflict of multiple heterogeneous positings will bring about adaptation, reconstruction, and even brittle fracture of the normative system. This study is the fourth paper in this series of ontological research. Keywords: Promise; Breaking-Temporality; Modal Gradient; Origin of Norms; Undecidable Domain; Illusion of Normative Traceability 摘要:元伦理学中长期存在先论之争:规范究竟来源于先天理性、自然秩序,还是人类实践的产物。康德式先验实践理性与自然法理论把规范奠基于在先的先天法则;而部分还原论又将规范简单等同于欲望、心理习惯或社会事实。本文依托本系列前序存在论成果,论证规范并非先验现成之物,而是个体与公共层面反复发生的立定‑破时性事件的历史沉积。通过重构「必须‑应该‑允许‑承诺‑喜欢」模态梯度,本文指出该序列不是义务强度的递进,而是约束来源的存在论层级区分:必须、应该、允许运行于已沉积的规范框架内部;承诺是发生在不可判定域的破时性原型操作,它创设出新的向后生效的规范约束;“喜欢”只是承诺完成之后衍生的主观感受,不能充当承诺的奠基根据。本文区分原型承诺(起源层面的破时创设)与日常框架内承诺;多重异质立定的冲突会带来规范体系的调适、重构乃至脆性断裂。该研究是本系列存在论研究第四篇。 关键词:承诺;破时性;模态梯度;规范起源;不可判定域;规范溯源幻相
Author: 许光
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: promise, metaethics, natural law theory
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225886434
