Field Intercomparison of Doppler SODAR and Wind Ranger 200 LIDAR for Urban Boundary Layer Wind Profiling
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study presents an intercomparison between a triaxial Doppler SODAR and a Wind Ranger 200 Doppler wind LIDAR in downtown Rome, Italy. It evaluates the measurement consistency and potential interchangeability of the two systems for long-term urban boundary-layer monitoring during a dedicated operational campaign. Measurements are compared at multiple heights in terms of both horizontal wind speed and the standard deviation of the vertical wind component, σw. Agreement is evaluated using bias, error statistics, correlation, and index of agreement. Below 100 m, horizontal wind speed shows strong agreement, with mean bias (MB) below 0.2 m s−1, normalized mean absolute error (NMAE) within 12%, and correlation (r) reaching 0.93–0.95. Above 100 m, metrics degrade significantly: MB increases up to 0.83 m s−1, NMAE rises to 23%, and correlation drops to 0.73. For σw, systematic differences are also small below 100 m, with MB up to approximately 0.04 m s−1 and NMAE of approximately 16–17%, although correlations are lower than for horizontal wind speed, with r ranging from 0.75 to 0.82. Above 100 m, the agreement in σw also deteriorates, with NMAE increasing up to 28% and correlation decreasing to 0.52. Overall, the results show that agreement between the two systems is strongly dependent on both measurement height and the atmospheric variable considered. The results demonstrate good operational consistency for mean horizontal wind speed below approximately 100 m under spring urban boundary-layer conditions. However, demonstrating full long-term record continuity across all annual regimes requires further multi-seasonal evaluations under stable nocturnal and winter conditions.
Source: Applied Sciences
DOI: 10.3390/app162211226
Language: English
Topic: Wind and Air Flow Studies
Subfield: Environmental Engineering
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,896
Funder: European Space Agency
OpenAlex ID: W7225890182
