Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: With the resurgence of rhetoric in legal practice, scholars have begun to explore how rhetoric can play a role in reasoning with evidence. In the "Story Model Theory," rhetoric plays a role as a narrative method, providing multiple story evaluation criteria from a psychological perspective, but it also has problems such as unclear relationship between evidence and story, selective storytelling and so on. Under the framework of the New Rhetoric, rhetoric is not limited to causal narrative, but rather all argumentative discourse that influences the audience's adherence of mind, and judicial proof should include three parts: justify oneself, compare with opponents, and persuade the audience. From the "structure-method" aspects of reasoning with evidence, on the one hand, in conjunction with the Toulmin model, rhetoric aims to influence the audience's judgment of warrant, including decisive conflict and degree contest. On the other hand, for other methods of reasoning with evidence such as argumentation, narrative, matching, analogy, and explanation, rhetoric can provide complementary reasons and for aspects not covered by these methods, while offering reinforcing perspectives for those aspects already in play.
Source: Research Square
Author: Yukun Luo
Institution: Renmin University of China
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225890550
