Work

An integrated analysis of the operational efficiency and network resilience of European railways

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Purpose This study aims to use a unified assessment framework to examine the operational efficiency and resilience of ten European railway organizations. Efficiency reflects the productive performance of rail systems, while resilience captures their capacity to recover from disruptions, accidents and external shocks. The purpose is to compare operators using comparable metrics, identify vulnerabilities and discrepancies between efficiency and resilience and provide insights to improve network robustness. Examining both dimensions, the study aims to contribute to strategic planning and infrastructure investment across European Union (EU) railways. Design/methodology/approach The analysis applies four data envelopment analysis (DEA) models: CCR and BCC to assess efficiency and resilience. Inputs include network length, electrification, rolling stock, labor and operational expenditure. The outputs include passenger-km, train-km and revenue. Resilience uses safety-related undesirable outputs, fatalities, collisions, derailments, injuries and other accident indicators. Emergency expenditure serves as an additional resilience measurement. Ten EU railway operators are selected based on geographic, structural and regulatory homogeneity. Findings The results show that although some operators achieve full efficiency, resilience performance is more heterogeneous. Greece, Slovenia and Croatia exhibit consistently strong performance across both efficiency and resilience models. In contrast, other networks exhibit high efficiency values but low resilience levels (e.g. Italy, Poland, Hungary under the CCR). This divergence suggests that operational efficiency does not necessarily guarantee robustness against disruptions. The resilience results highlight structural and safety-related weaknesses within certain networks, emphasizing the importance of investing in safety management, emergency preparedness and measures that enhance resilience, rather than focusing only on improving efficiency. Originality/value This study integrates resilience and efficiency within the same DEA framework for European railways. It provides a quantifiable and comparable metric of robustness by operationalizing resilience through safety-related outputs and emergency expenditure. This framework reveals misalignments that traditional efficiency analyses overlook, offering a more comprehensive understanding of railway performance. The study sheds light on the policy-making processes involved in prioritizing investment in safety, redundancy and adaptive capacity to strengthen sustainability and resilience.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7225890824
FWCI:
Cites: 44
Cited by:
Related to: 10