The Second Turn of Wealth Flows: Why the Affluence–Fertility Relationship Is Regime-Bound
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The inverse relationship between affluence and fertility is treated as a law of devel-opment. This paper argues that it is a regularity of a particular environment—thepost-Cold-War order and the pre-AI labour market—and that it rests on two precon-ditions the theory never states: that market and state instruments can substitute forchildren as old-age security, and that the return to concentrating a family’s resourceson one child’s quality is predictable enough to be worth the concentration. Both heldthroughout the period in which the relationship was documented. We set out fourdevelopments, stated as premises, that remove them together: the variance of re-turns to education rising faster than its mean; automation reaching work in order ofits profitability and leaving a residue of non-repeatable, low-return tasks; the struc-tural depreciation of wage-denominated claims against real assets; and the per-capitaform of transfer systems. Under these conditions children regain value through threechannels—as an in-kind claim on old-age support that passes through no market ortreasury, as a diversified portfolio against the obsolescence of any single skill, and asunits in per-capita redistribution—while the price of adequate education falls and thatof positional education does not. We read this as a second turn in Caldwell’s wealthflows: the intergenerational claim, nationalised and monetised at the transition, re-turns to the family in kind. The argument does not predict a return to high fertility; itpredicts the end of monotonic decline and its replacement by variation governed bystated scope conditions, and it sets out the observations that would falsify it.
Author: Sophia, Franny Philos
Language: English
Subfield: Demography
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225894145
