Work

How Far From Schwarzschild Can the Two Shadows Be? Deviation Bounds From Diameter Alone

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Define the fractional deviation delta as the observed shadow diameter divided by the Schwarzschild diameter predicted from an independent mass and distance, minus one. For M87*, delta is +0.058 with a combined width of 0.138; for Sagittarius A*, using the inferred shadow, delta is -0.086 with a width of 0.144, while using the emission ring instead would give -0.027, shifting delta by about six hundredths purely by a choice of definition. At two standard deviations the diameter data alone bound any spherically symmetric departure from the Schwarzschild shadow scale to 0.33 for M87* and 0.37 for Sagittarius A*. Those are the honest widths of the test. Geometries predicting deviations inside them, a class that includes many regular-black-hole and modified-gravity models at plausible parameter values, are not constrained by shadow size at all, whatever their other merits. Computed from published values; simulated, not measured.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225897148
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10