Work

No Complete Object: On the Truth-Generating Mode as Existential Guarantee

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The correspondence theory of truth takes complete in-itself objects as the benchmark for propositional mimesis, but this presupposition is built upon an "illusion of completeness." Building upon the ontological framework of the previous two papers in this series, this paper proposes a three-layered division of reality: potential reality, manifest reality (readings-sections), and grammatical reality. Grammar possesses a dual effect of revealing and concealing: while generating recognizable manifest reality, it inevitably filters and narrows the domain of possibilities. On this basis, the paper distinguishes between truth-false operations within a framework and the truth-generating problem of the framework itself, reinterpreting the truth-generating mode through existential guarantee (coupling stability): truth is not a mirroring mimesis of propositions onto complete objects, but rather the dynamic sustaining efficacy of a grammatical framework in maintaining systemic coupling stability when faced with continuously emerging anchors and readings-sections. This paper further demarcates its boundaries from correspondence theory, pragmatism, coherentism, and deflationism, tests this model through the brain-in-a-vat thought experiment, and responds to the self-referential aporia: "Since manifest reality has already been shaped by grammar, how can it constitute an external constraint?" Keywords: Sectional Reality; Existential Guarantee; Correspondence Theory; Grammatical Duality; Illusion of Completeness; Brain in a Vat 摘要:真理符合论以完备自在对象作为命题摹写的基准,但这一预设建立在"完备性幻相"之上。本文承接系列前两篇的存在论框架,提出三层实在划分:潜在实在、显现实在(读数-截面)、语法实在。语法具备开启-遮蔽的二重效应:生成可识别显现实在的同时必然对可能性域进行筛选与收窄。在此基础之上区分框架内部的真假运算与框架本身的成真问题,以生存论担保(耦合稳定性)重释成真模式:真并非命题对完备对象的镜像摹写,而是语法框架面对持续涌现的锚点与读数-截面时,维持系统耦合稳定的动态持存效力。本文进一步与符合论、实用主义、融贯论、消解论划界,借助缸中之脑思想实验检验本模型,并回应"显现实在已被语法塑形,何以构成外部约束"这一自我指涉疑难。 关键词:截面实在;生存论担保;符合论;语法二重性;完备性幻相;缸中之脑
Author: 许光
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225905865
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10