Work

Śraddhā as trans-empirical investment: a candidate construct and a comparative research programme on human distinctiveness

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: A stone placed under a tree, a river, a flag: each can stay physically what it is and still become a centre of hope, grief, memory and obligation that governs the people around it. This article proposes a candidate construct for the operation behind such cases and a programme for testing whether that operation is distinctively human. Existing accounts of faith and meaning-making, including terror management, attachment, the cognitive science of religion, sacralisation theory, and work on shared intentionality, norms and sacred values, explain much about how humans build and defend symbolic worlds. They rarely ask whether one capacity underlies investment in sacred and secular substrates alike. Drawing on the Sanskrit concept of śraddhā , read through Bhagavadgītā XVII, the article stipulates a technical construct, adṛśyaniveśana (trans-empirical investment, where “trans-empirical” means beyond what is empirically present): significance that refers beyond the present is placed in a substrate that does not itself contain it, and the invested substrate then regulates conduct. The target level (Level D) is defined by five conjunctive criteria, and boundary cases such as scientific hypotheses, money and ordinary norm-following are excluded. The framework is presented as derived from South Asian thought and addressed to a question of general relevance, not as universally normative; it is distinguished from pistis , fides , īmān and xìn as an operation on substrates rather than an attitude toward an object. Its distinctive predictions concern equivalence across religious and secular domains, the incremental value of its criteria, capacity transfer across targets, and the convergence of unshared individual investments on one shared substrate. No empirical data are reported. The Adṛśyaniveśana Index (ADI) is offered as a provisional item bank, not a validated instrument. Three hypotheses are specified with designs, smallest effects of interest and three-way decision rules (H1, H2, H4), conditional on prior development of the ADI items; one is stated briefly (H3) and one is marked exploratory (H5). A comparative paradigm for non-human species, testing a subset of the criteria, is outlined. An explicit safeguard holds that no claim about the capacity is a criterion of anyone’s moral standing.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,801
OpenAlex ID: W7225909239
FWCI:
Cites: 81
Cited by:
Related to: 10