Work

Testing the Crisis Plus One Theory in the Iranian Case: Institutional-Legal Analysis of Crisis Management Policy (1991–2026)

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article assesses Iran’s crisis-management institutions from 1991 to 2026 through Hamidreza Safari’s Crisis Plus One (C+1) framework. The framework treats a crisis not only as an emergency to be managed, but as a point at which institutions should learn, anticipate future risk, coordinate across agencies, build resilience and enable public participation (S1). A documentary, institutional-legal analysis examines legal texts, policy plans, governmental reporting and secondary institutional sources. The chronology begins with the 1988 edition of Standard 2800 as pre-history and follows three broad institutional phases: the formation and early expansion of national disaster institutions (1991–2007); statutory consolidation and planning (2008–2018); and the 2019 law’s implementation and accountability problem (2019–2026). The principal finding is a persistent evidentiary and institutional gap among four analytically distinct elements: (1) legal mandate, (2) delegated drafting, (3) budget authorization, and (4) verifiable implementation. The existence of a mandate or a drafting deadline does not establish an authorized appropriation, and neither proves execution or outcomes. Article 4 of the 2019 Crisis Management Law required preparation of implementing regulations within six months (S5); the August 2026 Parliamentary Research Center report no. 21772 records inadequate responses and an inactive monitoring system (S6). These records support concern about institutional follow-through, but do not establish that no implementation occurred. Data-quality problems include conflicting dates assigned to a 2005 national report and an unresolved dating discrepancy surrounding the 2026 report. C1I (concentration of power / structural rent dependence) is considered only as a proposed indicator requiring future operational specification. The article concludes that C+1 is useful as a diagnostic lens, while stronger implementation claims require auditable budgets, regulations, administrative records and outcome data. Keywords: Crisis Plus One; Iran; crisis management; disaster risk reduction; institutional learning; implementation; legal institutions.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225912032
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10