Work

The Corneliusgasse Dilemma: Adaptive Policing and Social Immersion under Deep Uncertainty

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Three scheduled Taylor Swift concerts in Vienna (August 8–10, 2024) were cancelled due to intelligence indicating the potential for immediate and violent terrorist action, followed by spontaneous gathering of disappointed fans in Corneliusgasse (a street in Vienna). This historical event motivates the generic analysis of a decision dilemma. The dilemma is the choice between two strategies that are formulated in the context of the Taylor Swift cancellation: static containment by the police of the fans at the stadium perimeter, or dispersal of the fans in Corneliusgasse with police immersed in the crowd. Given limited information available to the authorities, The Stadium scenario offers a better predicted outcome but it suffers from greater vulnerability to uncertainty. Conversely, the Corneliusgasse scenario is predicted to have a worse outcome but is more robust to uncertainty. In other words, the generic dilemma was the choice between a putatively better but more uncertain option, or a putatively worse but less uncertain option. Info-gap decision theory is used to quantify this dilemma, and to provide a basis for choosing between the options. From a sociological perspective, the paper explicates how and why this robustness is generated: the shift from a „Warrior“ to a „Guardian“ posture and the use of „rhizomatic immersion“ actively reduce the vulnerability to uncertainty in the Corneliusgasse scenario, thereby enhancing the robustness of the system against unknown threats.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225913131
Cites: 14
Cited by:
Related to: 10