Work

What asserted weights are worth: pricing a receptivity index in households and pre-specifying its test

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Agencies and firms allocate by rankings, so a specification error becomes a targeting error. We audit GCEIA, a deployed five-dimension composite of 3,106 U.S. counties. On the pre-specified proxies (2020 Census self-response and turnout, 3,097 counties), fitted models beat the composite (gradient boosting ρ = 0.758 and 0.770 against 0.634 and 0.157). Two dimensions do not earn their weight on one proxy, and the proxies disagree in sign about two. We revise the index on theory, not on those outcomes, and freeze it (GCEIA-R). The revision improves the Census correlation (ρ = 0.666, difference + 0.032, 95% CI [0.018, + 0.047]) and is neutral on turnout. On turnout the asserted and fitted top deciles share only 30 of 310 counties. Priced in households, rank disagreement overstates the cost: a plan contacting the top tenth of households reaches 73.9% self-responders under the asserted index against 67.7% untargeted, and neither the fitted model nor GCEIA-R differs detectably (at the one-tenth budget). The decisive test has not been run. We pre-specify it as a protocol: a five-year geo-randomized design, hierarchical weight learning from the GCEIA-R prior, and a top-decile capture bar, sized by design-based power analysis. Its contribution is the frozen design, not a result.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225914403
Cites: 15
Cited by:
Related to: 10