Work

Review Effectiveness in Generative Ai-assisted Sustainability Reporting: a Conceptual Analysis of Decoupling and Organizational Accountability

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can support the drafting and revision of sustainability reports, but the existence of human review procedures does not necessarily improve disclosure quality. Drawing on a theory-driven narrative literature review, this paper applies an organizational decoupling perspective to distinguish policy–practice decoupling, in which established review requirements are not implemented, from means–ends decoupling, in which review takes place but does not effectively serve disclosure quality. Building on research on human oversight and greenwashing, the paper examines the organizational processes underlying these two forms of failure. It develops a conceptual model linking evidence traceability, accountability relationships that enable questioning, and the integration of management controls. The theoretical analysis suggests that access to information, the authority to raise questions, and action in response are interdependent. Communications-oriented incentives may influence reviewers’ attention to different kinds of evidence, while feedback across reporting cycles influences whether corrections support organizational learning. Three propositions are developed, together with alternative explanations and boundary conditions. The theoretical contribution is to explain why human involvement can produce different outcomes and to distinguish procedural completion, disclosure quality, and sustainability performance. No new experimental or survey data were collected. The proposed relationships remain to be empirically tested.
Institution: ITMO University
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225982866
FWCI:
Cites: 15
Cited by:
Related to: 10