Abortion criminalisation and reproductive justice in Jordan and Tunisia comparing fetal protection, women's autonomy, and access to care
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article offers a doctrinal and normative feminist comparison of consensual abortion regulation in Jordan and Tunisia. It asks three questions: how consensual abortion should be distinguished from non-consensual and medically indicated pregnancy termination; how fetal protection should be balanced against women's dignity, health, equality, bodily integrity, and reproductive autonomy; and how the two legal models affect sexual-violence survivors, healthcare providers, and access to lawful care. Jordan adopts a predominantly restrictive criminal framework under Articles 321–325 of the Penal Code, while Article 12 of the Public Health Law No. 47 of 2008 creates a statutory exception where termination is necessary to protect the pregnant woman's life or health. Tunisia, by contrast, permits abortion during the first three months within a regulated medical setting and allows later termination on specified medical and fetal grounds under Article 214 of the Penal Code. Using a reproductive-justice framework informed by intersectional feminist scholarship, the article evaluates not only formal legality but also the distribution of risk, stigma, delay, and institutional power. It argues that sexual-violence pregnancy is a particularly revealing test of the proportionality of criminalisation, while provider regulation matters because it conditions whether formal legal entitlements can be realised safely. The article treats Tunisia as a functional comparator rather than a model for transplantation. It concludes that WHO's contemporary decriminalisation and abortion-on-request recommendations provide the stronger normative benchmark, while Jordan-specific reforms may also proceed incrementally through repeal of honour-based mitigation, expansion of lawful access, revision of provider aggravation, and procedural safeguards that avoid making legal access illusory.
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,180
OpenAlex ID: W7225984103
