Nonlinear drainage of a weathered and fractured granite aquifer inferred from spring recession analysis (Maupertuis, Brittany, France)
Year: 2026
Type: dataset
Abstract: How a weathered and fractured crystalline aquifer releases stored water during dry periods controls spring and stream low flows, yet it is usually inferred from a single recession law chosen by goodness of fit. We examined the drainage of the aquifer feeding a perennial spring in the Maupertuis experimental catchment (Brittany, France), using three dry-season recessions (459 daily values; 1999–2003 record, 5.9% missing days). The storage–discharge relationship was characterised independently of any fitted law through the slope b of −dQ/dt = aQᵇ and the instantaneous recession coefficient, and nine published recession laws were confronted with it, assessing calibration, out-of-sample forecasting, parameter identifiability, measurement uncertainty and data gaps separately. The slope b (1.43–1.81) excludes a linear reservoir every year and is close to the Boussinesq value of 3/2 in the two complete recessions. The instantaneous recession coefficient rises over the first 15–35 days and then declines, indicating a delayed contribution before baseflow drainage. The Tison–Boussinesq law, the only law derived from unconfined-flow physics, gave the best forecast for the longest recession. A quick component plus a slow exponential (Mangin law) fitted every recession best, consistent with compartments of contrasting properties in the weathering profile, but its curvature parameter was poorly identified and it ranked second out of sample. Laws with a constant baseflow floor forecast best over a few weeks in two years, yet their floors are contradicted by later low flows and by independent values recorded after a gap. Recession parameters differed significantly between years, and extrapolated drainable storage differed four- to five-fold between laws. Residuals were strongly autocorrelated for every law, so goodness of fit could not discriminate between them. These results yield transferable lessons for fractured aquifers: drainage is nonlinear, two-component fits do not prove two reservoirs, and fitted floors and single-event parameters do not extrapolate.
Institution: École Normale Supérieure d'Abidjan
Language: English
Subfield: Water Science and Technology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225986528
