Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Constitutional democracy mandates public participation as a mechanism for checks and balances against state power. However, the current political reality in Indonesia reveals a democratic paradox, wherein the opening of channels for freedom of expression clashes with the entrenched hegemony of elite interests (Hadiz & Robison, 2014; Winters, 2011). This article analyzes power dynamics and the tug-of-war between pragmatic political interests and the right to public participation, focusing on case studies of controversial legislation enacted with minimal civil society involvement. Employing a qualitative methodology utilizing case studies and a review of legal-political literature this research finds that the principle of "meaningful participation," as mandated by the Constitution (Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, 2021), has failed to be implemented substantively. The space for public participation has undergone a paradigm shift, reduced to a mere formality to satisfy procedural requirements (Fatmawati, 2020). Policy drafts are consistently steered by a consensus among political elites through practices of "legal authoritarianism" (Susanti, 2019) and the protection of oligarchic economic interests (Ford & Pepinsky, 2014), effectively sidelining public opposition. This study concludes that such imbalances in the power struggle not only undermine social justice but also pose a tangible threat of democratic regression in Indonesia (Power & Warburton, 2020). Consequently, there is a need to reconstruct the institutionalization of public participation—making it more legally binding—to ensure that the policymaking sphere remains resilient against the hijacking of transactional interests.
Institution: Muhammadiyah University of Makassar
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225993489
