Pre-registered predictions for the DESI five-year BAO results under five explanations of cosmic acceleration
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: We make three falsifiable predictions for the DESI five-year (Y5) BAO results, written on 12 November 2026, before those results are published (expected 2027). With an independent pipeline, we reproduce the published DESI DR2 BAO, compressed-CMB and supernova constraints to within 0.1 sigma, and compare five explanations of the current hint of evolving dark energy on identical data: a cosmological constant with a low-redshift supernova calibration offset, a thawing scalar field, a dark matter-dark energy exchange, and phantom-crossing (CPL) fits. Predictions:(1) Given the DR2 data, a DESI Y5 BAO + CMB preference for CPL below 2 sigma would favour no phantom crossing by about 3-5 to 1, and one above 3 sigma would favour a crossing by about 8-20 to 1; 2-3 sigma will not decide.(2) D_M/r_d at z = 0.51 will fall from 13.59 (DR2) to about 13.40-13.45, whichever dark energy model is right.(3) DESI Y5 BAO plus CMB alone will not establish a phantom crossing or detect a thawing scalar field. Files: the full note (PDF, 12 pages) and all code (11 self-contained Python scripts, Experiments 027-037) with numerical results (JSON). The analysis code was developed with the help of an AI assistant (Claude, Anthropic); all results were checked against published benchmarks.
Author: DUSHIMIMANA, Joel
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7225997632
