Work

Disciplinary Identity as the Missing Link: How Organizational Support Shapes—or Fails to Shape—the Scholarship of Teaching among Art Faculty in a Chinese Local University

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Three decades after Boyer's call to recognize teaching as scholarly work, the scholarship of teaching and learning (SoTL) remains unevenly institutionalized, especially in practice-based disciplines such as art and design, where embodied, tacit knowledge resists scholarly formats. Drawing on a qualitatively led mixed-methods case study in the art school of a local university in western China, this paper asks how organizational support is converted—or fails to be converted—into SoTL competence among art faculty. Data comprise a census survey of 92 faculty members, 10 in-depth interviews, non-participant observation, and institutional documents. Results reveal an uneven profile: strong identification with teaching as scholarly work, moderate inquiry-based instructional design capacity, and weaker engagement in evidence-based reflection and public dissemination. Hierarchical regression shows perceived organizational support predicted SoTL competence only in the first model, losing significance once educational leadership was added; leadership in turn lost significance once perceived artistic disciplinary characteristics entered the model (ΔR² = .319), emerging as the strongest predictor. Qualitative analysis illuminates the mechanisms: formal support met conversion barriers in decoupled policies, misaligned resources, and fragmented collegial culture, while multi-level leadership was pseudo-distributed—formally dispersed yet substantively uncoordinated. The study advances disciplinary identity—developed primarily from the qualitative analysis—as an interpretive filter conditioning whether and how organizational support becomes SoTL competence, with implications for faculty development across Asia-Pacific higher education.
Author: Xingxi Wu
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226012424
Cites: 26
Cited by:
Related to: 10