Work

A lossless four-bus power system with 18 real power flow solutions

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: For a lossless four-bus power system of PV buses with unit voltage magnitudes, Molzahn, Niemerg, Mehta and Hauenstein (arXiv:1603.05908) conjectured that the power flow equations have at most 16 real solutions, out of at most 20 complex ones. Lindberg, Zachariah, Boston and Lesieutre (arXiv:2010.03069) reported numerical instances with 18, without giving the parameters. We give explicit rational susceptances, b = (3, −56, −47, 33, 31, −51)/100 with zero power injections, for which the system has exactly 18 real solutions. The proof is an elimination to a degree-6 polynomial with exact arithmetic; it is checked independently by two interval-arithmetic programs, and the lower bound of 18 is checked in Lean 4 with Mathlib. This contradicts the conjecture of 16. Whether 20 real solutions can occur remains open. This work was carried out with AI language models (Anthropic Claude) under the author's direction. The models selected the problem, wrote the programs, found the instance by a computer search and wrote the proofs. The author has no academic training in mathematics. The programs are attached; the result was read by two AI reviewers from other providers. No specialist in the area has read this note. The author has not found an explicit instance with 18 real solutions in the literature but cannot rule out prior work.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7226012478
Cites: 2
Cited by:
Related to: 10